Makeup that lasts on very oily, acne prone skin + Tips!
If you are a person that struggles with very oily skin then you know that makeup can be more of a hassle than a pleasure. Dilated pores, blackheads, and of course, possibly acne and scars, as very oily skin is rarely clear. I suffered from medium to severe acne for many, many years, as well as having an extremely oily skin. Over the years I found products that worked even for my very stubborn, difficult to control skin.
This article is not meant to give skincare advice, and it will not go into detail about ingredients and routines. I will only focus on achieving the desired texture on the skin and on products that control that mad excess oil. A very seborrheic skin will have a lot of texture, and it will need all the extra help you can give it before applying your makeup. A silicone based primer for example will smooth the surface you are working with, allowing for a more uniform application of makeup. This, however, will block pores, so be aware of that. In terms of silicone based primers, I found that the High-Adherence Silicone Primer from The Ordinary made my makeup look as flawless as possible. It creates a layer on the skin – think of it as a thin cling-film uniformly spread on your skin – which allows the makeup to not sink in every pore and avoids thus to emphasize your skin texture. Buy here.
In terms of products that leave the skin to breathe more, I always liked the Clinique Pore Refining Solution Stay-Matte Hydrator, which although it contains silicones as well, it has a much lighter texture than The Ordinary primer, feeling more like a moisturizer. It is one of the only products I have ever used that noticeably controlled the oil production under makeup throughout the day.
Now, this is the trickiest one. An extremely oily skin will need strongly mattifying foundations, but all those acne fighting products will cause shedding of the skin and dryness in some areas. This is what I find the trickiest when it comes to finding a very good matte foundation – one that controls the shine and doesn’t over-emphasize the localized dryness of the skin.
Almost all ‘’matte’’ foundations would melt on my face in under two hours. Despite blotting the excess oil and using powders and everything you wish for, most foundations would not last on my very oily skin, but they would also emphasize the dry areas. The only one that didn’t move for many, many hours and did not bring attention to my dry areas was the Maybelline Super Stay 24h Full Coverage Foundation. This one looked matte on my skin for hours, and even once the sebum came through, it did not separate in the same way most foundations do.
The downside of it is that the shade range can be a bit odd. I have light skin with yellow undertones, and this foundation only has light shades with strong pink undertones. Although, this might have changed now, as I noticed they have added a lot more shades available. On the Maybelline’s American website, they seem to have light shades with yellow undertones, so this could be a weird, yet common case of varying shade ranges from continent to continent. In terms of skin tones, it is inclusive and well varied. It might just be a bit odd to find the right undertone as well.
It has medium coverage to full coverage, depending on how you apply it (with a brush, a wet sponge etc.) It is definitely not for the faint hearted ones though, and it will require some extra work after application, as it will erase every trace of colour and shade in your skin. Buy here.
The Rimmel Stay Matte powder is ideal for very oily skin types. It erases some of the texture of the skin, filling in the pores even more, and getting rid of any trace of shininess. It is also fantastic for acne – you can tap some powder on a cotton pad and press it onto a pimple. The mattifying of the area will give the illusion that the skin area is flatter, camouflaging some of the texture and inflammation. It comes in various colours, but I always prefered the translucent one. This is because with oily, acne prone skin you will use several layers of high coverage, and most will vary slightly in shade. The higher the coverage the higher the chance every mismatch in shade will be noticeable, so go translucent where possible. Buy here.
You will need two types of concealer – a creamier one for the under eyes area; and a matte, full coverage one for pinpoint concealing on the face. For the under eyes I always loved to use the Maybelline Instant Age Eraser Concealer as it does not take away all the luminosity and hydration from the delicate area under your eyes. Buy here.
For concealing imperfections though, you will need something matte and more substantial in texture. This is because you want to give the illusion of flat, untextured skin, and creamy concealers will bring more light and reflexions on the area, bringing unwanted attention. For pinpoint concealing I liked the Kiko Full Coverage Concealer. On their website it is advertised as ‘very high coverage concealer’, which I think it is not, but it is a good, reliable matte concealer.
The shade range is good but not ideal, as again, it will be difficult to find your perfect colour with the matching undertone. The trick is to find a product that has a perfect shade for you, as pinpoint concealing on the face only works if the shade is matching the rest of your complexion. What I mean is that, rather than focusing on the brand or a specific product, focus on the finish and on the shade. Buy here.
Bronzer, Contouring and Highlighter
I will not go into mentioning specific products, as there are many on the market that work for an oily skin. My tip for this category is to stick to powder products rather than cream ones, to further erase the skin texture and to mattify the skin even more. You may find that after applying bronzer and blush you will need to re-do some of the pinpoint concealing. You will need a lot of patience, so take enough time to do your complexion.
In terms of highlighter, I personally avoided using one most of the time, as I had acne on most of my face, and I did not want to bring even more attention to it. A good highlighter should not emphasize the skin texture, but it also depends on the application. Stick to less, and never go overboard. The advantage of a very oily skin is that it will be glowy on its own.
If you do want some recommendations for this category, you can watch my fast reviews, as well as finding some of my favourites here.
Over the years I tried several setting sprays in my obsession to make my makeup last longer, but at the time I could not afford any of the pricier ones that were promoted everywhere online. The one I used that worked was the L’oreal Infallible Fixing Mist, but it also irritated my skin slightly, and I avoided using it unless I had a special occasion. The problem with setting sprays is that most contain alcohol, which will dehydrate and irritate the skin, potentially encouraging it to produce even more oil. I must confess I am not the biggest fan of setting sprays. Buy here.
Tip: Blotting paper
Blotting will be your best friend if you have very oily skin. Every few hours you will need to gently blot your skin to absorb some of the excess oil coming through the makeup. You can purchase blotting paper from various brands, or you can genuinely use fine toilet paper or tissues. Just make sure that you do not rub the tissue or the paper on the skin, but rather very gently tap.
Please let me know in the comments below what are your holy grails when it comes to very oily, acne-prone skin.
Disclaimer: All pictures in this article are ©Lipstick Café.
This article is not sponsored but it contains some affiliate links. This means that I make a small commission if you decide to purchase through my links. Take it as a small thank you for me sharing with you my timeless favourites. It is also a nice way for you, my readers, to give back to me without actually spending extra money, so thank you. The use of affiliates does not influence my reviews and opinions, as my main goal for Lipstick Café is to provide excellent, unbiased content, worth coming back to.
Very interesting and informative. Despite being well past my teenage years I still have very greasy skin. Great post.
Hi Karen, thank you for your comment. Oily skin is not necessarily linked to our teenage years, it is a skin type that some of us have all our lives! I am glad you find the article interesting.
Gee, this was really helpful. I use tissue paper and setting spray to remove oil from my skin.
There is nothing wrong with tissue paper as long as it’s soft!
Mrs. Type A
Such great tips! I always feel like I need to re-apply make up after just an hour. Where does it go?!?
Oil dissolves makeup unfortunately, so if we have very oily skin, the sebum will break through the makeup and ruin it, which is why in my opinion doing your makeup on very oily skin is the most difficult task! I am glad you find the tips helpful!
Primer has been the best thing I’ve found. I can’t believe I went my 20’s without it.
It’s not always necessary!
Iris C. Permuy
Thanks for all these great tips!
Hi Iris, I am glad you found the article helpful!
Looks like really awesome products!
Hi Devin, I am glad you liked the article!
Adventures with Shelby
These are great makeup suggestions
Thank you, I am glad you found them useful!
I don’t have oily skin but I use Superstay by Maybelline. It’s suitable for all skin types, gives this matte look and blends well with my powder (foundation or pressed powder) unlike some that gives this ‘cake’ effect on the face.
Oh wow, I never tried it on a different skin type, it’s good to know! I love it for the non-cake effect as well!
Thanks for the recommendations, I have to check these makeup whenever I got back to the USA. My face can get oil at times (especially before or during a period), so I would like to try these makeup products to see if it makes any difference on my face.
Let me know how it goes!
Well , I will be trying the maybelline foundation as I have been finding a foundation that actually suits my oily skin since a long long time .Thanks
Let me know how it goes!
Would this work on combination skin? I don’t get super oily, but in certain spots I am prone.
Hi Michele! I have not tried these on combination skin. Depends how oily you get in your T zone. The products I mention here worked well on very oily, acne prone skin. On a less oily skin they might be too drying.
This is really perfect for my daughter. She can determine exactly what products are ok with her skin type. Will share this to her.
Hi Elizabeth, thank you so much! I hope she will find it useful!
I have combination skin but I’ll make sure to refer this article to my sisters <3
Hi Maria, thank you so much!
I haven’t been a fun of make up but with these tips I might consider getting into it. I have oily skin and mild acne prob.
Oh I do hope some of these products will suit your skin and look gorgeous! Makeup is fun and first and foremost we should be enjoying applying it!
So many great products in this article. I am looking forward to trying some of them!
Hi Danielle, I am glad to hear that!
Thank you so much!! I’ve always struggled with oily skin, and these products and tips are amazing! Loooove it!! (IG: @susi_belmonte)
I am really glad the article was helpful!
You are helping me SO much!